What’s so controversial? The Truth About Netflix Documentary: Seaspiracy
Netflix’s Seaspiracy is a documentary directed by and featuring Ali Tabrizi, a British filmmaker, that was released in 2021 and emphasizes the various environmental consequences of uncontrolled fishing. With its surprising accusations and statements, this latest Netflix documentary has left people astonished. This brief documentary video raises awareness about the growing amount of plastic garbage and trash in water sources, as well as the issue of overfishing in different regions of the world. The film has earned some positive reviews, yet it was also condemned and criticized by certain audiences and even marine experts.
It begins as an environmental documentary attempting to study whale stranding but quickly transforms into a voyage into the impacts of industrial fisheries. The film attempts to reveal the unlawful seafood trades, that do have deep, secret cultures of crime, exploitation, and scam featuring huge corporate figures and political support, using secret recording devices, and shooting in risky settings. Seaspiracy covers huge distances, starting from Asia to Europe and the United Kingdom, uncovering new information upon this sector whilst keeping the spirit of seriousness.
Are the facts conveyed in Seaspiracy reliable?
Despite its portrayal as analytical reporting, the Seaspiracy documentary spreads misinformation and fake news and has been criticized by specialists, authorities, and even the show's actors. According to the documentary, the fishing sector has been engaging in animal mistreatment, which is a big issue in today's world. The film also mocks the idea of a sustainable fishery, which is seen as an environmentally beneficial approach for helping the earth flourish while rewarding everyone. The video also discussed the brutal labor that is routinely employed in the corporate fishing sector.
When discussing the crisis of pollution in the water bodies, the Seaspiracy series claims that plastic fishing traps account for 46% of the concern. It misinterprets data from a 2018 research that stated that fishing nets made up at least 46% of the plastic in the Great Pacific Garbage Patch.
No doubt, there is an issue with marine debris, but the portrayal and absence of awareness of primary scientific knowledge is a significant mistake. Even as the documentary focuses on subjects that have never been addressed previously, some of these shocking findings have had the viewers taken aback and they are in search of an honest Seaspiracy review. Numerous experts from around the world have criticized the director and the documentary for their absence of fact-based accuracy and misinterpretation.
What experts have to say about the film:
Seaspiracy, according to Ray Hilborn, a professor at the University of Washington's School of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, "is not a documentary but a propaganda film made by vegan activists." He argues that several fisheries have been responsibly administered for hundreds of years whereas, for countless people, the fishing industry is indeed a vital source of nutrition and work.
In addition, numerous participants of the documentary have criticized the documentary for being misleading. The video, according to Mark Palmer, associate US director of the International Marine Mammal Project, takes his comments out of reference. In addition, the organization issued a statement regarding the film.
In reaction to the concerns stated in the film, the Marine Steward Council has issued a detailed response. In rebuttal to the claim "There is no such thing as sustainable fishing," they wrote: "This is incorrect. One of the remarkable things about our seas is that, with proper long-term management, fish supplies may recover and replenish ". Furthermore, discussing the benefits of sustainable fishing, the organization added, "While we disagree with much of what the filmmakers of the Seaspiracy documentary say, we do agree that our oceans are in a state of overfishing. However, millions of people all across the world depend on seafood to meet their protein requirements. With the world's population expected to exceed 10 billion by 2050, it's more important than ever before to manage the natural resources properly, and sustainable fishing is critical to the preservation of such assets."
The Bottom Line:
Millions of individuals worldwide depend on fisheries as their main supply of protein, as well as the fisheries sector, which supports countless people's occupations. Even if we assume that all of the director's assertions are accurate, and users wish to ban fishing activities and compel everybody to depend exclusively on plant produce, making the transition immediately, or even over the next few decades, will be difficult. However, moving towards a sustainable lifestyle is the need of the hour, with the ongoing environmental crises, and we should all do everything in our capacity to revert the inflicted damage, be it making small changes in food habits, to making little switches in our daily use products. Various internationally recognized environmental research works have concluded that an average vegan person would leave behind far lesser amount of carbon footprints than an average non-vegetarian person. Brand GoingZero endorses a sustainable, vegan, chemical pollutant-free lifestyle, and you can visit us at www.Goingzero.in to know how to make those little switches in your day to day life.
Written by: Soniya Sanyal